Trade Media Purposely Hype 3D TV Study?
Washington, D.C. (May 25, 2011)
-- The Digital Entertainment Group, the industry trade group
whose mission is to promote CE products, such as 3D TVs,
yesterday released a study saying that early 3D TV owners love
Considering DEG's reason for existing, the study's conclusions
shouldn't come as a surprise to anyone. But this is the technology
business, which is often blessed with unchallenging, even
worshipful coverage from the trade media assigned to cover it.
For instance, Multichannel News yesterday ran a story on the
study with the headline, "3DTV Owners Ecstatic About Home
Entertainment Experience." No where in the story did
Multichannel News report that DEG represents 3D TV makers and
other companies who stand to benefit from the sale of 3D TVs.
But Multichannel did lead its story with these two paragraphs:
it comes to their 3D TV sets, owners of the equipment greatly
enjoy their home viewing experience, rate the quality of picture
extremely high, believe the upgrade was well worth the
investment and don't even mind those glasses.
Those were among the key conclusions drawn from a new study
polling some 3,065 3D-capable set owners that was commissioned
by the DEG: The Digital Entertainment Group, the results for
which were released here today at the NewBay Media Summit on
"Connected TV and 3D: Delivering the Demand." NewBay Media is
the parent of Multichannel News."
Hmm, the study was released at a 3D TV conference run by
Multichannel's parent company. How sweet.
Twice Magazine published a similar story on the study with the
headline, "DEG: 3D TVs Get Good Consumer Reviews." Again, no
where in the article is it mentioned that DEG is in business to
promote 3D TV, among other CE products. But Twice did mention
that it, too, is owned by NewBay. Yes, the same NewBay who's
running that 3D conference.
Yes, a conference that stands to benefit by promoting 3D TV.
Do you see a theme here? Two major trade media outlets wrote
highly positive stories about a 3D study commissioned by an
organization whose goal is to promote 3D TV, but they never
mentioned that fact in the articles. But they did acknowledge
that their parent company is running a 3D TV conference, which,
of course, will benefit from the promotion of 3D TV.
Is this journalism?
Now, I'm sure that the trade publications, or DEG, will point
out that DEG commissioned the research firm SmithGeiger to do
the study. But let me point out that SmithGeiger's business is
based largely on winning over clients in the TV industry. This
is from SmithGeiger's web site:
of the top fifty-five television markets are influenced by our
counsel, several of the biggest names in cable and satellite
television are SmithGeiger clients, and the most important
companies in consumer technology and multimedia entertainment
look to us for insight and expertise in building and maintaining
their brands & products."
(And let me also point out that it's not difficult to commission
a study that's designed to achieve certain results, particularly
if the research company is cooperative. And most of them are;
that's what they are in business for.
It's all in how you phrase the questions; phrase the questions
just right and you can get a study that says Coke people love
Pepsi. I'm sure SmithGeiger does a great job with research
studies, but it should release the 3D study questions, and the
methodology, and let everyone decide for themselves.)
This little incident is yet another example of how consumers are
being ill-served by the media at large and tech journalists in
Amazon's HDTV Store!
to see today's Swanni Sez.
Phillip Swann is president and publisher of TVPredictions.com.
He has been quoted in dozens of publications and broadcast
outlets, including CNN, Fox News, Inside Edition, The New York
Times, The Washington Post, The Chicago Tribune, The Financial
Times, The Associated Press and The Hollywood Reporter. He can
be reached at email@example.com
Click TVPredictions.com to read
more news and features on TV technology.
|Swanni Sez has 10,000+