Home
Swanni Sez Archive
HD Heaven
About
Contact
Advertising
Product Reviews
Press Release
Service
Subscribe
Hire Swanni
Free News Service
Advertising

      


 

 
News Feature
DIRECTV's HD DVR: Better or Worse?
In a new edition of "Ask Swanni," your humble high-def guru answers your questions.
By Phillip Swann

Washington, D.C. (December 28, 2006) -- I get scores of e-mails every week from readers asking everything from whether they should buy a new HDTV to when will their TV provider add new high-def channels.

So, from time to time, I will publish my responses here in this new column called, "Ask Swanni!"

Q.
Last week, you ripped the new DIRECTV HD DVR apart. Is it working any better? -- Sandy K. 
Last week, I reported that DIRECTV's new high-def recorder
(HR 20) has generated customer complaints around the country for faulty recordings and other software bugs. Personally, I had to reboot the device about 25 times and make several calls to the company's Customer Service department. Finally, DIRECTV sent me a replacement unit, which also had trouble recording shows as scheduled.

However, after two more reboots this week -- and two more calls to Customer Service -- the HD DVR seems to be working well. The machine actually has recorded seven straight shows without a glitch. Of course, on Christmas Day, every channel went black except for my local channels. However, after another reboot -- and another call to Customer Service -- the channels returned. (The Customer Service rep blamed the HD DVR.)

So, bottom line, I am hopeful that DIRECTV is close to working out the kinks. I am not ready to recommend it yet. But, yes, I am hopeful.

Update: Sorry, I have to take back my hopeful words. Last night I recorded three shows on DIRECTV's HD DVR. Tonight, after I originally published this column, I tried to watch them. No dice. They all failed to record. And so it goes.

Q. You said that DIRECTV will add 40 HDTV channels next year. Do you know which ones?  -- Matt P.
Actually, David Hill, DIRECTV's president of entertainment, told TVPredictions.com that the satcaster will carry at least 40 HDTV channels by mid-2007. However, he did not specify which channels will be added.

Q. Any predictions for the new Laser HDTV? Will it destroy LCD and Plasma? -- Mark S. 
Mitsubishi says the new "Laser TV" will be introduced in 2007 and it will use lasers instead of lamps to send images to the screen. Consequently, the picture could be sharper than current flat-screen sets. However, until it's launched, it's just talk. And Plasma and LCD makers have a big head start.


The Toronto-based 'Naked News' service.

Q. I saw your story about the "Naked News" criticizing Consumer Reports' rankings for high-def sets. Should I think twice about using Consumer Reports for high-def advice? -- Barney B.
Consumer Reports offers comprehensive and thoughtful reviews of new high-def sets. And there's no doubt that the magazine has a strong track record. However, like any review, it's one person's (or organization's) opinion. You should consult several sources before buying.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------


Q. Are you planning any special coverage for the Consumer Electronics Show? -- Fred P. 
Glad you asked. We will offer blanket coverage of next month's trade show, with several daily stories on new HDTV product announcements and related news. The conference will run the week of January 8.

Q. I went to a B.J.'s wholesale club recently and saw a Sony 40 and 46-inch 1080p LCD. The pictures were stunning. Is there any chance the picture won't look as good in my house? -- Michael L.
The two sets could have been connected to a Blu-ray HDTV DVD 1080p player, which purports to offer sharper images. In that case, you would need a Blu-ray player to get the same picture. Generally speaking, the picture on an in-store set can be great or terrible, depending upon whether the set has been tuned or which picture source it's displaying. (cable, satellite, DVD, etc.). You can't base your buying decision entirely on how a set looks in the store.

Q. When will Comcast add new HDTV channels? I read on the Internet message boards that it was supposed to be this month. -- Michael H.
Comcast is preparing to add more high-def channels, such as A&E HD and National Geographic HD. However, some local Comcast systems do not have enough bandwidth at this time for the additions. That's why some Comcast subscribers are now getting new HD channels while others are not. However, the cable operator is moving to improve system infrastructure across the country so it can add more services and channels. In fact, it just announced plans for a big system expansion in the Northern California area.

Q. I would love to see you add a Message Board feature at TVPredictions.com so we could post comments and ask questions of fellow readers. Is that possible? -- Cathy C.  
You would be surprised at how costly and time-consuming it is to create and maintain a Reader Forum. However, that said, I hope to add one in early 2007. Stay tuned.

Click TVPredictions.com to see today's Swanni Sez.

© TVPredictions.com
____________________________________________

Phillip Swann is president and publisher of TVPredictions.com. He has been quoted in dozens of publications and broadcast outlets, including CNN, Fox News, Inside Edition, The New York Times, The Washington Post, The Chicago Tribune, The Financial Times, The Associated Press and The Hollywood Reporter. He can be reached at swann@tvpredictions.com or at 703-505-3064.

Click TVPredictions.com to read more news and features on TV technology. 
 

 
 
Daily E-Mail Newsletter!

Sign Up for Swanni Sez!
Delivered to your e-mail box.

* Email Address:   
Swanni Sez has 10,000+ subscribers!
 
Search TV Predictions


TVPredictions.com

Hundreds of articles on TV Technology

More HDTV Links:
HDTV Review: The XBox HD-DVD Player
Rogers Cable: Over 200,000 HDTV Subs
Peyton Manning Blurry On HDTV?
OPPO Launches 1080p DVD Player
HDTV Owners: The New Homebodies?